Navigating divorce when a business Is involved: Practical guidance for Welsh business owners
Navigating divorce when a business Is involved: Practical guidance for Welsh business owners
Subscribe to the Businessin Wales daily newsletter for FREE here.
Divorce is challenging for any family. When a business or commercial interest is part of the picture, the process can feel particularly complex. Whether you own a family company, hold shares in a private enterprise, or run a sole trade or partnership, careful preparation and specialist advice will help protect value, minimise disruption, and support a fair financial settlement. Leah Thomas, Head of the Family & Matrimonial team at Harding Evans, offers some practical guidance.
Initial considerations for business owners
Early clarity is vital. Take stock of what you own, how it is held, and who controls decision-making. Identify shareholdings, directorships, partnership interests, options, loan accounts, intellectual property, contracts, and any trusts or offshore structures connected to the business. Gather the core paperwork: company accounts, management accounts, tax returns, bank statements, shareholder or partnership agreements, and key contracts. This information will underpin negotiations and any expert valuation.
Understanding disclosure duties matters. Financial remedy proceedings require full and frank disclosure. Attempting to conceal assets or depress value can damage credibility, escalate costs, and invite adverse inferences by the court. Accurate disclosure, presented clearly, strengthens your position.
Consider liquidity and cash flow. The court aims for fairness, not to harm a viable business or the livelihoods it supports. Where possible, settlements should avoid forced sales or excessive borrowing that would jeopardise operations. Think about what you can afford in terms of lump sums, staged payments, or alternative structures, and whether dividends or drawings are sustainable.
Protect business continuity. Put in place sensible governance measures to reduce disruption. Ensure there is clarity about remuneration, expense policies, and dividends during proceedings. Avoid major transactions without advice, particularly those affecting value, control, or liquidity.
Respect confidentiality. Divorce proceedings are private, but commercial confidentiality still matters. Limit internal circulation of sensitive documents, use appropriate confidentiality undertakings, and manage communications with staff and stakeholders carefully.
Protecting business interests without undermining fairness
The family court in England and Wales exercises a wide discretion, guided by section 25 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 and the overarching objective of fairness. Where a business was built during the marriage, it is commonly treated as part of the matrimonial asset base, although needs and sharing will drive the outcome. Where interests pre-date the marriage or derive from third parties, arguments about non-matrimonial property may arise. Good advice helps frame proportionate, evidence-based proposals that recognise both the provenance of the business and the parties’ needs.
Practical protections include maintaining robust, up-to-date accounts and management information, ensuring arm’s length dealings, and avoiding steps that could be criticised as value manipulation. Director loan accounts, surplus cash, and retained earnings often feature prominently; anticipate questions about distributable reserves and tax. Partnership and shareholder agreements can clarify transfer restrictions, valuation mechanisms, and the consequences of a change in personal circumstances. If such agreements exist, ensure your legal team reviews them early.
Understanding the financial implications
The route to settlement typically blends three elements: needs, sharing, and compensation (rare). The court will consider housing and income needs for both parties, children’s welfare, and the resources available, including the business. Outcomes range from offsetting (retaining the business in exchange for reduced claims elsewhere), lump sums paid over time, to limited reallocation of shares where appropriate. Clean-break solutions are often preferred, but only if they are fair and workable. Tax is integral. Decisions about dividends, extraction of profits, and any sale or refinancing should be made with tax advice, as ill-timed or poorly structured steps can trigger avoidable liabilities.
Why specialist advisors matter
Complex business cases benefit from a coordinated team. A family solicitor experienced in business assets will lead strategy, disclosure, and negotiation. An accountant or forensic accountant can advise on cash flow, tax, and valuation inputs. Where pensions are significant, a pension on divorce expert can be essential. If property assets are involved, a RICS valuer may be required. Early engagement saves time, sharpens negotiations, and reduces the risk of missteps.
The business valuation process, explained simply
Valuation is usually addressed through a single joint expert (SJE) accountant, instructed by both parties and reporting to the court. This promotes independence, proportionality, and cost control. The SJE will gather information, apply accepted valuation methodologies, and produce a report that can be clarified by written questions. While parties may sometimes seek their own advice to test assumptions, the SJE’s opinion often carries significant weight.
Different approaches may be used, depending on the nature of the business:
- Earnings or cash flow-based valuation: The valuer assesses maintainable earnings and applies a multiple (or capitalises cash flows), adjusting for factors such as risk, growth prospects, and market conditions. For smaller private companies, normalisation adjustments may be made to directors’ remuneration, one-off expenses, or related-party transactions.
- Asset-based valuation: Appropriate where value resides in tangible or investment assets rather than trading profits, for example in property holding companies or businesses with significant plant and machinery. The valuer considers net asset value, sometimes on a fair value basis.
- Dividend or income approach to minority interests: For minority shareholdings with limited control and marketability, discounts for lack of control and lack of marketability may be applied. The valuer may also consider expected dividend flows rather than control-level earnings.
- Hybrid or cross-checks: Valuers often triangulate, using more than one method to cross-check the reasonableness of their conclusion.
In family cases, multiple “values” may be discussed:
- Enterprise value: The value of the business as a whole before debt.
- Equity value: Enterprise value minus net debt, representing the value attributable to shareholders.
- Proportionate share value: The value of the specific interest held, after applying any appropriate discounts for minority holdings or illiquidity.
- Realisable value: What might realistically be achieved if a sale were contemplated, net of costs and tax. Courts often prefer to avoid hypothetical sales, but the practical ability to extract funds is relevant.
- Maintainable earnings and surplus cash: The valuer may distinguish trading value from surplus or non-core assets and from directors’ loan accounts, which can affect settlement structuring.
The SJE’s instructions are critical. They should define the interest to be valued, the valuation date, the basis of value, information to be reviewed, and the treatment of discounts. Your solicitor will ensure the questions asked are clear, proportionate, and focused on the issues that matter to settlement.
Practical steps to take now
Engage a specialist family solicitor with a strong track record in business cases. Collate core financial documents and keep management information up to date. Seek early input from a financial advisor or accountant on cash flow, tax, and affordability. Keep decision-making measured and well-documented. Consider interim arrangements for remuneration and dividends during the proceedings. Be open to structured solutions such as staged lump sums or offsetting that preserve business viability while meeting needs.
Final thoughts
With the right preparation and expert team, divorces involving businesses can be resolved fairly without undermining the enterprise you have built. Early specialist legal advice, clear disclosure, and a measured approach to valuation are the foundation for a durable settlement that safeguards both the family’s future and the business’s long-term success. If you are a business owner facing separation or divorce, consult a solicitor experienced in business assets at the earliest opportunity to secure timely, tailored guidance for your circumstances.
Want more from Businessin Wales? Why not follow us on our socials
Listen to the Businessin Wales podcast
